Putin here, Putin there

He is hated, accused, defended. His face is everywhere and has become the epitome of the war of aggression against Ukraine. Now the rumour mill is boiling over about what might be wrong with Vladimir Putin. Is he mad? Does he have cancer, AIDS, Parkinson’s, or all of them at once?

Why Putin is waging this war has, since it began, been the notorious hook on which almost every piece of journalism hangs itself. Outside Russia, however, there is nothing but speculation: claims are made and what-if scenarios discussed. Anyone reporting directly from Russia faces fifteen years in prison for carelessly speaking truths, while the West stays at tabloid level journalistically. Whoever ventures into the war zones and reports from there has nothing to show but destruction. Nothing that distinguishes this war from others. And the reports from correspondents on the ground seem like side issues when “experts” then spend minutes on end setting out their hypotheses.

The “open societies” are proving that they lack the means and the imagination to end this war. American media in particular report on how things stand with the president and on how he could / must / would be removed. Doesn’t that turn Putin into the head of a monster? What, then, is its body made of? A few generals and ideologically loyal tycoons? That would mean that Russian women and men have no say in their country — and it seems that way.

Herein lies the mistake of the international community: recognising the oligarchy as such by regarding only its “heads” as representative of an entire people. The citizens of Russia thus become invisible, their strength underestimated. Hence removing Putin, one way or another, appears to be the liberation of a country. That is evidently the West’s conventional strategy: liberation from above.

From recent history we know where this kind of thing ends. The coup d’état in Iran, the split between Sunnis and Shiites in Iraq, the endless tragedy in Afghanistan. Afghanistan, though, shows that at least a seedling of democracy did develop — even if it was trampled within a few days. Afghanistan revealed the difference between militarily propped-up liberality and actual democracy. The latter was impossible, because the Taliban did not need free elections. They had the weapons, because the West had empowered them to fight decades earlier.

In the same way the West is empowering, for example, the extremist Azov Regiment by supplying weapons. It is laying the future foundations of conflict and unfreedom by arming parts of the population. In the medium term this hands Putin arguments for a war against nationalist-fascist tendencies.

By contrast, no thought is given to empowering Russian citizens, which could remove the cause of the war at its source. At its core lies the strengthening of democratic structures, which would render Putin and the Russian oligarchy irrelevant. How that can happen is food for thought for all those who proclaim the openness of their society.

Dieser Post ist auch verfügbar auf: German